TheUtmostTrouble TheUtmostTrouble
Notifications
Clear all

1. Group A---edesmond26

11 Posts
6 Users
0 Likes
56 Views
Posts: 296
Admin
Topic starter
Member
Joined: 7 years ago

Is it important to follow family traditions? Where in your story do you see this? If you don’t, what are you seeing instead? 

Vietnamese has a huge language barrier between English because it doesn't have subjunction, which means there language doesn't have what if scenarios, its either it happened or it didn't, Phuc's dad would get mad at him when he stopped working for a couple months because he had a reason, because he didnt understand the reason, only that he wasn't working. But his Dad then finally started to understand a little more and wanted Phuc to do what he wanted with his life and encouraged him but it took him a bit to start to understand. Some quotes from this video that show his struggle to understand are, ¨I remember talking to my dad about this, and because he´s a non-native speaker of English, he didn't quite grasp all the nuances of the subjunctive¨ (Tran) and ¨Imagine then going from a language with no subjunctive, like vietnamese, to a language with the subjunctive-rich fabric, like english¨ (Tran). 

     Out of Nowhere by Maria Padian, the story follows Tom Bouchard, a popular high school soccer player, and his cousin Franny Powers, who is more independent and outspoken. Tom goes to an upscale prep school in Maine, where he navigates his life as a teenager and tries to fit in too much. We also meet Ishmael, a Somali refugee who recently moved to the area. He struggles to fit in at the school due to language barriers and racism. Some students are nice to him, but others, like Hank, treat him bad. There was a soccer game with Tom's team against Ishmael's team and he is targeted by Toms team because of his background. 

        The connection between the video and the book is the language barrier, Phuc's dad had a hard time understanding English, and the subjunction. This is similar to Ishmael because he is having a hard time speaking English and completing full sentences because of the language and the culture changed when he was moved to Maine. Some quotes from the book that show the connection with the video and book are, “But you still have choices, no matter how big or small your luck quotient is” (Padian 29), this quote is explaining that luck is something you cant control, but you always have choices to shape your own future, for Ishmael that might be starting to make the choice  understand this new culture and language barrier and “Sometimes he surprised me and came up with a string of English that made you think he could speak the language. Other times he faded and I couldn’t tell if he was just not getting the words or avoiding a topic” (Padian 96), this quote is showing Ishmael's hard time understanding this new language and he sometimes understand this new culture but other times he doesn't.  


For participants: 

-Never use a peer’s real name, only use their username

-Respond to the question based on your book, not your personal opinion

-If the question doesn’t directly apply to something that appears in your book, be clear about what you’re seeing instead

-Make sure to include a summary of your book so far

-Include a quote with the proper citation to give context to your answer

-Reply to one other participant in this group

-Acknowledge your lead’s reply to your response with a comment that clarifies information, offer a question to them about their book, or simply give a thumbs up

To exceed: Reply to three other people in this group, or two in this group and one in a group you weren’t assigned

10 Replies
Posts: 296
Admin
Topic starter
Member
Joined: 7 years ago

In my story, Sigh, Gone, Phuc Tran talks more about this relationship with his dad. Early in the book he describes what his life was like as a young child refugee. His Vietnamese family moved to Pennsylvania after they needed to relocate. Because there is no diversity where they move, Phuc is immediately singled out. There are many times that Phuc does his best to help himself and his family fit in, but there are limits to what his father was willing to do. Phuc's father insists that he needs to learn Vietnamese, so when Phuc refuses, because he doesn't want to be the weird immigrant kid, his dad beats him. To his father, it was a non-negotiable, "How are you going to read Vietnamese? Are you going to be a Vietnamese person who can't read their own language?" (Tran 58)

To Phuc, being Vietnamese was the problem, not something to continue diving deeper into. For him, thinking about his future as an American, Vietnam didn't seem important. To his father, knowing it would be difficult for them to ever go back, and not willing to put his family at risk, Vietnam is everything important. Phuc even details how the local paper got involved in his grandparents' relocation from Vietnam, "The arrival of more Trans was headline news for our drowsy town." (Tran 70). But things start to change when he writes a story about their relocation. He ends up winning a prize for a writing contest for his essay and realizes, "Words were powerful. They could destroy you, and they could save you, too. And maybe earn you a hot Happy Meal---thankfully." (Tran 71). 

Just knowing and continuing to use the language of your culture can be extremely important. Phuc and his experiences, even though he's resistant, show why family, their traditions, their values, their involvement, ultimately are beneficial. 

Reply
2 Replies
Joined: 4 months ago

Protobeing
Posts: 10

In both of are book both are main characters are family orientated. and both try and help there family's seek refuge and fit in with the new world around them. 

Reply
Joined: 4 months ago

Protobeing
Posts: 14

How do you think Phuc’s understanding of the power of words in his essay changes how he feels about his dad and his Vietnamese background and culture?

 
 
 
Reply
Posts: 10
Protobeing
Joined: 4 months ago

In my book The Grief Keeper by Alexzandra Villasante, this book is about a young girl trying to escape from a latin american country because of gang violence and vendettas and she seeks refuge in the united states, he then tries to escape from being deported and  gets picked up by a governmental person and is forced to be in a experiment for her freedom.In my book so far you don't see much for her family traditions, because after her brothers death, they flee into the united states..” Due to an unfortunate incident involving marisol's older brother, their family has come under the bad influence..”(Villasante 10).  In my book she does speak Spanish, and does value her family because she is trying to get refuge for her family.

Reply
1 Reply
Joined: 4 months ago

Protobeing
Posts: 14

How do you think Marisol’s relationship with her family and her desire to protect them influences her actions and decisions while she’s in the United States?

Reply
Posts: 13
Protobeing
Joined: 4 months ago

Girl In Translation By Jean Kwok is about a young Chinese girl immigrating to the U.S from Hong Kong, trying to accustom to the new morals and ways of life. Kimberly and her mother live in a very run down, bad apartment in the projects of New York, a place that was basically abandoned. Kimberly has to attend public school, where she has some challenges in the beginning, but eventually makes a good friend named Annette. Annette shows her the ways of life in the U.S and eventually Kimberly gets the hang of school there, and gets very high math tests scores, and was able to be a candidate to go to a private school. On top of school, Kimberly has to go to the factory where her mother was employed after school to work very long hours, sometimes being there all night with her mother.

To Kimberly and her mother, the Chinese traditions they had brought from the U.S from Hong Kong were very important and were to still be followed. Kimberly has to accustom to the new ways of life in the U.S, while still following the morals and traditions inherited from her mom. One quote where it shows this is where Kimberly's mother tells Kimberly they still have to "repay their debts" which is one of the traditions and morals the Chinese hold on to and follow. "She's given us housing and a job. She's my sister and your aunt. And no matter how flawed someone else may be, that doesn't give us the right to be less than we are, does it? We are decent people and we repay our debts." ( Kwok 88 )

Reply
1 Reply
Joined: 6 months ago

Protobeing
Posts: 13

That quote just goes to show that no matter the flaws of the tradition, they will still stick to it. But I do wonder if getting accustomed to the U.S will change those traditions at all?

Reply
Posts: 9
Protobeing
Joined: 4 months ago

In my book Americanized, by Sara SaedI. She talks about being naive when they moved to America not knowing they could easily be kicked out of America since they aren't there legally. They end up getting a social security card so the government knows they are there. She then goes on how she struggles during school because of her looks and comparing herself to others, especially her skin color, especially with boys and wanting to be liked, and in a relationship. 

In my book there are no family traditions, but Instead I do see her parents trusting her on what she wants to do, regardless of their opinion on it. “As much as their parenting philosophy was “We trust you,” “You can trust us.” (SaedI 73)

Reply
1 Reply
Joined: 6 months ago

Protobeing
Posts: 13

Do you think she hides her traditions as to not get bullied, or she just doesn't have any to begin with?

Reply
Posts: 13
Protobeing
Joined: 6 months ago

There are many ways that the main character in the book Behold the Dreamers by Imbolo Mbue practices family traditions. Jende first gets to move to the U.S. even if he doesn't have any papers, second gets to move his family over and gets married to his girlfriend, and finally gets a good job being a driver for a very wealthy man and his family. Despite living in New York, Jende regularly sends money back home to support his family, which is a common practice in many African cultures where family bonds and responsibilities are highly valued. ¨Every month, Jende sent money to his parents in Cameroon, no matter how tight things were¨”(Imbolo Pg 45).

Reply
Share: