TheUtmostTrouble TheUtmostTrouble
Notifications
Clear all

1. Group H---jmartineau26

7 Posts
5 Users
0 Likes
42 Views
Posts: 296
Admin
Topic starter
Member
Joined: 7 years ago

How do the limited perspectives of other people in society shape the understanding of minorities and what assumptions do these perspectives reveal about racial biases? Where do see examples of these assumptions in your book? 

 

In “The Danger of A Single Story” the writer, Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie speaks about reading books as a child and how they were all foreign, American or British stories about white children and white things, and how that shaped her interpretations of all stories regardless of where they were based and when she started to read books from Africa, she realized that people like her existed and their stories could be spread. When she went to a university in the U.S and a student stated that it’s a shame that all African men are abusive after reading a book she wrote, she replied stating that it’s a shame that all Americans are cold blooded murderers after reading American Pyscho,flipping the script that many people who never left their home countries and how they interpret people of different races based of simple subjective stories. “I recently spoke at a university where a student told me that it was such a shame that Nigerian men were physical abusers like the father character in my novel. I told him that I had just read a novel called ‘American Psycho’ and that it was such a shame that young Americans were serial murderers.” this quote shows a prime example on how little information on different cultures can be harmful if negative and marginalizes people in said cultures.

 

Another example comes from “Born A Crime” by Trevor Noah, in this book, Trevor grows up in South Africa, where they face apartheid and oppression from the government which forbids interracial relationships, his mother is African and his father is of European, because of this racism is apparent on both sides, in the book, He describes how Colored kids would sometimes try to claim him, seeing his lighter complexion as an affiliation.  But he wasn't Colored in his family or cultural background.  Then, when he interacted with white people, there was always a sense of otherness, a subtle reminder that he wasn't one of them. "Because I was light-skinned, people assumed I was Coloured.  Coloured people assumed I was white.  And white people, well, white people weren't sure what I was, but they knew I wasn't one of them." (Noah, Chapter 6) this shows how peoples limited knowledge for people who’s heritage and hesitancy because of said differences can come off as ignorant hate instead of simple questions.


For participants: 

-Never use a peer’s real name, only use their username

-Respond to the question based on your book, not your personal opinion

-If the question doesn’t directly apply to something that appears in your book, be clear about what you’re seeing instead

-Make sure to include a summary of your book so far

-Include a quote with the proper citation to give context to your answer

-Reply to one other participant in this group

-Acknowledge your lead’s reply to your response with a comment that clarifies information, offer a question to them about their book, or simply give a thumbs up

To exceed: Reply to three other people in this group, or two in this group and one in a group you weren’t assigned

6 Replies
1 Reply
Joined: 4 months ago

Protobeing
Posts: 10

In my book “Out of Nowhere” by Maria Padian, it follows a guy named Tom Bouchard in a town in Maine called Enniston which is a predominantly white town. The High School that Tom goes to has become a place where many Somali refugees have begun attending. Many of the townspeople view Somali refugees as outsiders who are reluctant to assimilate. This is because of stereotypes within the white community which fails to recognize the struggles refugees face which can consist of language barriers, discrimination, and trauma. For example, Tom’s grandmother and his friend Donnie get frustrated with the Somalians presence because they assume that they just get special privileges and they take advantage of resources without contributing to the community. Tom's initial beliefs about Somali refugees are heavily influenced by the other people around him, one example that shows the biases others have around Tom is shown when Tom and Donnie say, “‘ They don’t wear bedsheets. Get with the cultural program man.’ ‘Whatever’ Donnie said. ‘I don’t see why this is getting to you. Who knows what the hell they're thinking behind those burkas? Who cares?’” (Padian 60). Although his perspective begins to change when he meets Saeed and as he spends more time with him. In turn this later helps Tom to build his own perspectives and reveals that his previous beliefs were based on ignorance instead of reality. 

Reply
Posts: 296
Admin
Topic starter
Member
Joined: 7 years ago

In my story, Sigh, Gone, Phuc Tran talks about how is THE minority. Early in the book he describes what his life was like as a young child refugee. His Vietnamese family moved to rural Pennsylvania after they needed to escape the war between North and South Vietnam. Obviously the kids at school notice how he's different, doesn't understand English, and is wearing extremely limited clothes. He finally starts to get into fights with the kids at school, one specific time because another student, Derek, calls him a gook. Even though he doesn't know what it means, he knows it is an insult and he punches the other kid in the face. 

He continues to work on making himself feel more American. He refuses to learn Vietnamese with his dad. He tries to wear similar clothes as everyone else, even though his family can barely afford the bare minimum. He even goes so far as starting to make fun of himself to avoid others making fun of him. And even though he gets several kids to laugh, Derek isn't impressed, "'You're still a gook. I don't care what you say. Still. A. Gook.' And he was right. I couldn't change his mind about that. I wielded no control over how he saw me. I would always be a gook to him." (Tran 68). 

So I think there's room for people to grow and learn how to treat minorities in ways that make sense for their culture and awareness, but there will also always be racial bias. Even when Phuc can convince the rest of his classmates that he's actually funny, Derek's opinion will never change. Unfortunately, it also feels like there isn't much of an expectation in the story, or in society, for Derek to change. Phuc doesn't even report his torment after the first time because there were no consequences for Derek continuing to use a racial slur. 

Reply
Posts: 6
Protobeing
Joined: 4 months ago

In my book Behold the Dreamers by Imbolo Mbue. The main characters Jende Jonga and his wife Neni move to America from Cameroon. To have a better life for themselves and their six-year-old son. Jende lands a job as a chauffeur for Clark Edwards who works as a senior executive at Lehman Brothers a big corporation. Through this job, he is able to support his family and pay for his wife to go to college.

to make extra money Neni during the summer works for Mrs. Edwards as a nanny to help with their child Mighty. Through working this job Neni sees the limited perspective that Mrs. Edwards has towards Africa and African people. Mrs. Edwards said “No you don’t understand,” she said. “Being poor for you in Africa is fine. Most of you are poor over there. The shame of it, it’s not as bad for you.”(Mbue 123)

This quote shows how flawed Mrs. Edwards's view of Africa is, viewing it as a backwater place where everyone is poor and no one has anything and implying through this quote that the shame that she might feel being poor is so much worse than somebody in Africa just because she’s American. She's saying that my feelings have more weight to them because I was born in a more important country than you. I think this sense of superiority over minorities and immigrants is very prevalent in society and the quote does a good job of showing that.

Reply
2 Replies
Joined: 4 months ago

Protobeing
Posts: 14

Wow, I mean just wow. This was an amazing and breathtaking summary of the story so far. We are both reading the same book and, If I can just say, you have blown it out of the park. My summary isn't even worth half of this! (and that's putting it lightly) I definitely can see how Mrs. Edwards comes off as rude or how her view of Africa is largely based on American stigmas of Africa and you explain that extremely well. Bravo, Dbubier, bravo. I think that you definitely deserve your four. Love you. 

Reply
Joined: 4 months ago

Protobeing
Posts: 16

I agree! That is a very impactful quote

Reply
Posts: 16
Protobeing
Joined: 4 months ago

In the book “Out of Nowhere”, Maria Padian tells the story of a senior in high school, Tom Bouchard, who lives in a small Town in Maine. Tom's life is relatively quiet and peaceful, except that he plays soccer for his school team. But his season changes with the arrival of several Somali refugees. Especially one named Saeed, which Tom develops a great curiosity and admiration for his soccer skills about. Saeed doesn’t speak a lot of English, so Tom, as captain of the team, offers to help him, and eventually become very good friends. Unfortunately, Tom and his friend Donnie get caught when sneaking into another highschool and painting their rock. Tom is punished with 100 hours of community service, and has to repaint the rock. At school, groups of immigrants are arriving. Most of them can’t speak English and it's really hard for them to communicate, which leads to a great segregation based on different cultures, religions, languages, etc.

In this book, some people assume that immigrants don't know anything about America, its culture, past or history. Even the main character, Tom, thinks Saeed has probably never heard of football: “I was matched up with Saeed for quick passes and warm-up drills, which should have put a smile on my grouchy face because the guy is the Tom Brady of passing accuracy. And yeah, I’m mixing my metaphors here, but hey, I like football. It just bugged me that I couldn't say that to the guy. Couldn't even complement him. First, because there was no way he knew who the New England patriots were, and second, because his English suckied.” (Padian 41). This hinders the communication between people and makes it harder for the Somalian immigrants to talk to Americans and make themselves known. 

Reply
Share: