TheUtmostTrouble TheUtmostTrouble
Notifications
Clear all

3. Group E--psmith26

6 Posts
4 Users
1 Likes
29 Views
Posts: 315
Admin
Topic starter
Member
Joined: 7 years ago

“Immigrants make democracy stronger”– Sahu Bhojwani

Is a story about how Sahu went from living in India to Belize to America in order to pursue her education. It was here that she started an organization about helping immigrants like herself. She wanted to encourage immigrants to vote and get involved in their communities, despite their fear of things in a society where they are casted out. “New Yorkers who were in city government holding positions had no idea how scared immigrants were of law enforcement.”(Bhojwani 3).

In my book “ Out of Nowhere” by Maria Padian, Tom is a senior in high school and captain of the soccer team. His season is changed when Somali immigrants join the team and they are very skilled and better than pretty much everyone else on the team. One of these players is named Saeed, who Tom quickly befriends and even helps him fill out the permission slip so that he's allowed to play. With the help of the new teammates the soccer team starts winning games however Tom makes a big mistake, he and his troublemaker friend Donnie decide to paint their rival highschools special rock. They get caught in the act and everyone is mad at Tom, his parents, his coach, his principal, everyone. Tom gets sentenced to 100 hours of community service and has to repaint the rock back to how it was. At school the immigrants have a hard time finding classes and navigating the school because they barely know English. The confusion leads to other kids making fun of and picking on them which creates a hostile environment in the school. What doesn't help is the rule that the school puts in that students are only allowed to speak English in classrooms which makes it very difficult for the immigrants to communicate. Tom has to start doing his community service at a learning center for immigrant children. Here he meets Myla, a college student who Tom likes, however Tom has a girlfriend which makes things complicated. Tom goes there everyday after school to get his hours in and to see Myla. The soccer team continues to go well with the help of Saeed and the other immigrants. However in the most important game of the year against their rivals Maquoit, Ramadan is happening, so none of the immigrant players can eat or drink anything all day or during the game. Against the odds they beat them and everyone is hyped. Tom eventually breaks up with his girlfriend and starts seeing Myla, and everything in his life starts going great. However things start to go downhill, Maquoit questions the eligibility of Saeed so he isn't able to play. The whole team is angry about this and Saeed especially, when a huge storm comes in and the whole town loses power Saeed goes missing and everyone is worried. That same night, Tom gets a call from Donnie's mother saying that he was in an accident and is seriously hurt. Tom goes to the hospital and through the night most of their classmates show up to check up on Donnie. Tom sees Saeed’s sister Samira who never really liked Tom but Tom gives her a hug to comfort her because she's stressed about her brother missing. However Tom's ex-girlfriend sees this and takes a picture and posts it on facebook, this is very bad because Somali girls are not supposed to touch men. The whole Somali community is mad at Samira and Tom doesn't understand why. Saeed still doesn't show up and the team loses their playoff soccer game. Finally Saeed's family contacts the police and reports him missing.While Tom was being interviewed about Saeed by the police investigators Saeed walks into the house. As it turns out he was in Portland at a soccer game the night of the storm and just couldn't find a ride home. Tom tells Saeed about what happened between him and his sister but Saeed seems upset by it. Tom just doesn't understand why it's such a bad thing but that's just how it is in the Somali community. Soon after, Saeed's family was gone. Nobody knew where they went and they just vanished. Tom was upset about the whole situation and one day while studying with Myla, Myla showed him an email from Samira saying that they were okay and how they moved to Minneapolis. They were living there with their uncle and other relatives. And although Tom was sad they were gone he was still happy that he knew them.

A quote that shows where characters were experiencing fear is when Myla explains to Tom how the Somali community feels about police. “But I do know this: the police are a last resort to these people. They don't want any trouble, and their experience is that guys who carry guns are not necessarily out to help you.” (Padian 265)

Where are your characters experiencing fear? And what is the outcome?


For participants: 

-Never use a peer’s real name, only use their username

-Respond to the question based on your book, not your personal opinion

-If the question doesn’t directly apply to something that appears in your book, be clear about what you’re seeing instead

-Make sure to include a summary of your book so far

-Include a quote with the proper citation to give context to your answer

-Reply to one other participant in this group

-Acknowledge your lead’s reply to your response with a comment that clarifies information, offer a question to them about their book, or simply give a thumbs up

To exceed: Reply to three other people in this group, or two in this group and one in a group you weren’t assigned

5 Replies
Posts: 16
Protobeing
Joined: 5 months ago

In  Trevor Noah's Born a Crime (my book), fear is a recurring theme throughout his life as he grows up in apartheid and post-apartheid South Africa. The book is a memoir that details Trevor's experiences as a mixed-race child in a society where his very existence was illegal. His mother, Patricia, raised him with resilience and defiance, constantly navigating the dangers of a system designed to oppress Black South Africans. The memoir explores themes of identity, racism, and survival as Trevor tries to find his place in a world that doesn't fully accept him.

One example of fear in the book is Trevor’s mother’s constant concern about law enforcement. Because interracial relationships were illegal under apartheid, she had to go to great lengths to protect Trevor, often pretending he wasn’t her son in public to avoid arrest. This fear dictated many of their daily actions, as she had to be cautious about where they went and how they behaved in public.

Another instance of fear is when Trevor, as a teenager, gets involved in a CD-selling business in a rough area. He faces the threat of gang violence and corruption, realizing that survival often depends on understanding unspoken rules in dangerous environments. This fear comes to a head when he is arrested for driving a stolen car, and he experiences firsthand the flaws and brutality of the legal system in South Africa.

The outcome of these fears varies. Patricia’s fear drives her to be strong and resourceful, ultimately shaping Trevor’s resilience. However, Trevor’s experience with the police serves as a harsh lesson about systemic oppression, reinforcing the idea that fear is a tool used to control marginalized communities. Like Out of Nowhere, the book highlights how fear influences decisions and relationships, especially for those who feel like outsiders in their own society.

Reply
1 Reply
Joined: 5 months ago

Protobeing
Posts: 17

I like how you connected Trevor's mothers fear of law enforcement to my book, considering it was a main fear of the Somali people in my book

 

Reply
Posts: 23
Protobeing
Joined: 7 months ago

In my book Out Of Nowhere by Maria Padian, Tom is a senior in high school while also being captain of the soccer team. During the season there is a bunch of Somalian kids who join the team after immigrating and they are better then almost all of the kids.The best one is named Saeed, Tom and Saeed become good friends and they even got so close that Tom filled out Saeed's doctor things with his so Saeed can play on the team and since he is an immigrant he doesn't have a doctor or a dentist or any of the things to be able to play. Tom and his trouble making friend Donnie went and painted rival schools Maqoit's special rock.They get caught and then Tom gets sentenced to 100 community service hours and him and Donnie have to paint the rock to how it was before. The immigrants have a hard time finding there classes and navigating the school. The principal makes a dumb rule and makes its so the immigrants have to speak American and not just there language which makes it even harder for the immigrants to understand there classes and talk to people to get help. Tom's life starts going pretty well he breaks up with his girlfriend and starts dating Myla, Maquoit questions Saeed's eligiblity to play and he is then stopped from playing and then when a big storm strikes Saeed goes missing and his friend Donnie gets into a accident and is very hurt. At the hospital Tom hugs Saeed's sister and then Tom's ex girlfriend gets upset and take a picture and uploads it. The whole Somalian community gets upset at Saeed's sister's. Saeed was in Portland at a soccer game the night of the storm and just couldn't find a ride home. Tom tells Saeed about what happened between him and his sister but Saeed seems upset by it. Tom just doesn't understand why it's such a bad thing but that's just how it is in the Somali community. Not much longer after that Saeed's family just left. Tom is very upset about loosing his friend but finds out that they moved to Minneapolis to get away from the bad stuff and threats about Samira hugging Tom. A quote that shows Saeed's family being scared when Saeed is missing is when " The family was scared. Petrified, actually Mrs. Bashir looked practically catatonic" (Padian 286)

Reply
2 Replies
Joined: 5 months ago

Protobeing
Posts: 17

Do you think that if Saeed and his family had stayed Tom would have faced backlash from the Somali community, or do you think maybe Saeed would've just stopped being friends with Tom because of the incident?

Reply
Joined: 7 months ago

Protobeing
Posts: 23

I feel that Tom being the person he is he would rather have taken the backlash from the Somalian community then stop being friends with Saeed.

Reply
Share: