TheUtmostTrouble TheUtmostTrouble
Notifications
Clear all

#2 Chick Red 1---ivalentin24

12 Posts
6 Users
0 Likes
161 Views
Posts: 278
Admin
Topic starter
Member
Joined: 7 years ago

How does assimilating into a new culture get mixed into an immigrant’s old one? Should there be limits to how much an immigrant assimilates?

 

For example…

In Private Label by Kelly Yang focuses on two Chinese immigrants Serene and Lian. Serene is fully assimilated, whereas Lian has more recently immigrated to Southern California. Lian’s mother is pushing him very hard in academics while he wants to pursue stand-up comedy. To help with this he creates his own after school book club. Lian is also struggling with assimilating and feeling discriminated against, even down to how people pronounce his name. Serene’s mother has pancreatic cancer, and is trying to connect more about her father throughout this process. Meanwhile her boyfriend, Cameron, is pressuring her to pursue things in their relationship she might not be fully ready for. “‘Ugh, that sucks. Just because you’re Chinese, she's making you join it?’ Quinn adds, ‘that’s terrible, I mean, you're not that Chinese.’” (Lee 116) is an example on how Serene is assimilated and how her culture does not does not directly apply to the one she is in. 

 

In “What marrying an immigrant taught me about cultural bias” by Kyle Quinn it talks about how an American man and his Brazilian wife are discriminated against in a trip to the BMV. The attendant refuses to help them upon seeing her temporary green card, but then agrees to help them after he shows he’s an American citizen, “This cultural bias that's exhibited towards her is culturally insensitive comments. They don't come from a place of concern about who Isabel is as a woman, her values, her morals, her ethical framework. They come simply from a place of concern that she's not from here to no fault of her own…” (Quinn)

 

Both the main characters and some of the minor characters are being pressured to not pursue their values, rather than be their authentic selves.

11 Replies
Posts: 29
Protobeing
Joined: 2 years ago

In Girl In Translation by Jean Kwok Kim doesn't face the problem of maybe assimilating too much. Kim more is slowly easing into it all, she is taking this slowly and is very cautious of everything around her. Kim was thought of as being very intelligent at her old school and her new school. She doesn't quite have that intelligence yet because of her language and learning barrier with the new school and knowing little english. “Mr. Bogart wrote a large “0” on my paper and gave it back to me. I felt as if the zero were fluorescent, blinking in neon to the rest of the class. What would Ma say? I’d never gotten a zero before” (Kwok 27) Kim never got bad grades at her old school so her new school has definitely put a challenge on her because she isn't all that good at reading or writing English but she still tries her best.

Reply
4 Replies
Joined: 2 years ago

Protobeing
Posts: 21

So If Kim is slowly assimilating, is the social aspect of assimilating basically non-existent? 

Lian in my book (who is also a main character) was basically having the same issue with being new to the school. However, Lian was actually quite forced to be assimilated in a rude way, like people calling him Liam instead of Lan and people throwing away his brochures for his Chinese club. These actions that people do towards him cause him to feel oppressed to assimilate and instead make him distant from any new social topics.

Reply
Joined: 2 years ago

Protobeing
Posts: 29

yes,i would agree!

Reply
Joined: 2 years ago

Protobeing
Posts: 38

This is very interesting. This relates to my book as well because in my book Linh's dad was a very good marketing man. He could sell anything to anyone. But when he moved to America he had a hard time learning the language and he sounded unprofessional so he wasn't able to continue with that career choice. 

Reply
Joined: 2 years ago

Protobeing
Posts: 37

in my book, Tom is helping a young Somali boy with homework and he gets it wrong so the kid must redo the homework, the kid was very distraught and worried about his grade, how do you think Kwok reacted to getting the 0 on her test.

Reply
Posts: 37
Protobeing
Joined: 2 years ago

In Out of nowhere by Maria Padian there is a large group of Somalis that are living in this American town and Samira a Somali immigrant herself is trying to teach immigrant kids to speak and read English so that they can better understand and live in America the main character Tom is also helping with this and is learning more about the Somali population and way of life with this he learns how hard it is for some of the immigrants to live in this new world because they have a hard time assimilating with the American way of life. "'English is hard for him,' she said. 'but not for you I pointed out. 'I am good at school,' she said.".(Padian 174) this points out and exemplifies the problems with assimilating and how that cultures don't mix well and how you can't really limit how much one culture assimilates into another.

Reply
3 Replies
Joined: 2 years ago

Protobeing
Posts: 29

Wow, I love how you explained and showcased how you cant really cap the amount that a culture assimilates into a different one through your quote.

Reply
Joined: 2 years ago

Protobeing
Posts: 20

This is a really good example and nice quote. 

Reply
Joined: 2 years ago

Protobeing
Posts: 21

This is a perfect example of what i was asking for! In my book, there is clearly a division as to where cultures cannot combine and contradict one another. great quote!

Reply
Posts: 20
Protobeing
Joined: 2 years ago

In Almost American Girl by Robin Ha my character Chuna does not really experience her culture after she moved. At her school no one excepts her and no one really gives her a chance. Home is really the only place she feels a little more comfortable in because her Korean family but even there she sometimes feels like an outsider. She had lots of friends back in Korea so this was a very hard change for her. On the other hand her step cousin Lena is very assimilated into the American culture. She dresses the same as everyone else, speaks the same language and this is very hard for Chuna to understand because Lena is Korean. "I was used to hanging out with goofy tomboys like me. Lena was demure and feminine: The kind of girl that my friends and i would mockingly refer to as a princess." (Ha 83) 

Reply
1 Reply
Joined: 2 years ago

Protobeing
Posts: 21

I can also relate to Lena being assimilated well and Chuna not in my book private label. Serene in my book is a popular Chinese immigrant in high school while Lian is a fairly new immigrant from china who gets picked on and refers to Liam even though he despises the name.

Is Chuna experiencing a rude awakening when i comes to her assimilating into the new culture?

Reply
Share: