TheUtmostTrouble TheUtmostTrouble
Notifications
Clear all

1. Group H - ccurran25

4 Posts
4 Users
0 Likes
98 Views
Posts: 268
Admin
Topic starter
Member
Joined: 7 years ago

Where are you seeing characters struggle to deal with expectations in your story? How do they deal with the expectations that are being put on them? Who is putting expectations on them? 

 

 In the Ted TalkGrammar, Identity, and the Dark Side of the Subjunctive Phuc Tran talks about how different languages can make a big barrier between two people because some languages like Vietnamese which is where his family is originally from. He talks about the struggles of talking with his father. This is a struggle because Vietnamese doesn't have “what if” or “would have,” so when talking to his father he had to be careful how he said things because if he didnt there would be a miscommunication. He talks about us having patience with either: people who are learning a now language, or someone that only knows one language because there are language barriers. 

In this quote from the Ted Talk, he has decided that he is no longer happy with his major and wants to change it;“I sat down With my dad that December to tell him that I didn't want to major in art in English anymore as I awaited some reprimand from him.. my father was completely calm, without a hint of disappointment... There was no ‘you should’ speech from him… Instead this is what he said:” you don't want to major in art in English anymore. That's fine, don't study what you don't like, what do you like? study that.” (Tran). This quote works for the connecting point between the video and my book; because when he is sitting down with his dad and as he awaited a lecture from his father, he realized his father was calm and all he said was if you don't want to do that then don't do what makes you happy. 

 

In the novel “My Father, the Panda Killer.” by (Jamie Jo Hoang) it splits the story between Jane and her father, Phuc. Jane lives with her little brother Paul, and her father Phuc who is an escaped immigrant. Jane is 17 and wants to go to college but is terrified to ask her father for permission to go. She is afraid of being beaten for wanting to leave and not work at the store like her father. She is also afraid of her brother hating her for leaving like their mother. When Phuc was young he had to try to escape his hometown to get to America; but fails the first time and lands up getting an older man killed because of his  arrogance. The second time he succeeds and gets out of his home town.  Jane finally spills about being accepted to college at dinner when her fathers company was visiting.  The lady was questioning her if she would like to go to college or if she's undecided; when this happened she couldn't take the pressure and just yelled out that she'd been accepted. Her father to her surprise just said okay and nothing more. 

In this quote from  “My Father the Panda Killer.” by Jamie Jo Hoang She was sitting at the table with her father and his friends when the lady asked her about college and her reaction was ““The assumption that I'm not smart enough to get into college that cost me to blurt out, ‘“I got into UCLA.’”... instantly, I regret saying this-for multiple reasons. ‘“ The Orientation is August. August 17th, is that okay?’”  I asked, turn into my dad. ‘“Okay.’” Okay? I'll find out if you really mean it later. “ brother, he was such a high achieving daughter and all by yourself. Cheers,” But my dad always jokes. " If this works, it could be good for both of our families. " … " but we never know, right? maybe she'll fail all of her classes.””(Hoang 93). This also shows the connection between the video and my book because she is expecting her father to freak out but all he lands up saying is “okay” and that was it.   

 Both talk about having parental expectations impact their decisions. Neither people get the response from the parent that they were expecting.


For participants: 

-Never use a peer’s real name, only use their username

-Respond to the question based on your book, not your personal opinion

-If the question doesn’t directly apply to something that appears in your book, be clear about what you’re seeing instead

 

-Make sure to include a summary of your book so far

-Include a quote with the proper citation to give context to your answer

-Reply to one other participant in this group

-Acknowledge your lead’s reply to your response with a comment that clarifies information, offer a question to them about their book, or simply give a thumbs up

To exceed: Reply to three other people in this group, or two in this group and one in a group you weren’t assigned

3 Replies
Posts: 21
Protobeing
Joined: 1 year ago

In my book “ The Leavers” By Lisa Ko  is about a young Chinese Boy named Deming from a city called Bronx located in New York. he lives in a small apartment with his mother and family friends who has a boy Deming’s age named Michael. His mother works in a salon and doesn’t come till night. Deming’s mother says she got a new job in Florida but he doesn’t want to move. Later on his mother does not come home  from work and disappears with no notice. Now that his mother has left him he stayed with the family Vivian, Leon, and Michael but they could no longer afford him because of  Leon moving to work in China and Michael, so Vivian put him in foster care and he  found a new family to live  upstate with, Kate and Peter Wilkinson. He then changed his name to Daniel Wilkinson and got adopted. Moving into a new family and starting at a new school he is not academically good with his grades. 

Based on my book a quote that relates is , “ And now, whenever we go out, I”m suspicious. Are people looking at us because I have blond hair and he has black hair? Or is it more nefarious? It's making me paranoid.” ( Ko 75) Deming's foster mother Kate is scared that people are going to judge them, she is not used to the adjustment yet and  thinks that she is doing something wrong. She is expected to take care of Deming and  knows that Deming needs help and wants to try her best to take care of him. 

Reply
1 Reply
Joined: 1 year ago

Protobeing
Posts: 16

 

I also see people being worried about not fitting in or being judged. When Jane goes to school she tries to fit in with a group of girls and she is scared of being judged or deemed of being weird.  “They asked me what kind of food I ate, and when I gave a boring answer of rice and eggs, I could tell they were disappointed, so I started listing off the things I knew would gross them out… And when they began laughing, I took that as a good sign, so I continued… I brought up everything and anything I thought might entertain them, and then they ditched me as a friend. I guess I should thank them for the early lesson on “fighting in" because I never made that mistake again.” (Hoang 17)

Reply
Posts: 5
Protobeing
Joined: 1 year ago

 In my book Girl In Translation by Jean Kwok it is about a family who emigrated from Hong Kong to New York which includes an 11-year old named Kimberly Chang and her mother who she calls Ma. They both only speak a little bit of English which definitely is a clear struggle from them, once they moved to America they struggle with the moving as they cannot find an apartment that is somewhat livable, they explain how the apartment has a lack of heat, no real furniture, and backbreaking labor.  Despite Kimberly’s culture she embarks on a double life as an astonishing student who isn’t really good at understanding English and a sweatshop worker with her mom on the evenings and weekends. 

 

This upcoming quote in my novel that relates is. “My English mistakes clearly annoyed him, although I wasn't sure why. Mr. Bogart wrote a large “0” on my paper and gave it back to me, I felt as if the zero were fluorescent, blinking in neon to the rest of the class.” (Kwok 26) Kimberly was using her “resources” by cheating and trying to see another girl's paper as Kimberly wasn’t aware of what she was supposed to be doing as she didn't really understand English and Mr. Bougart didn't explain it clearly to her which causes a lot of confusion and struggles that Kimberly has to face throughout her school journey. 

 

Reply
Share: