TheUtmostTrouble TheUtmostTrouble
Notifications
Clear all

2. Group D - mlevasseur-robbins25

9 Posts
5 Users
4 Likes
49 Views
Posts: 72
Admin
Topic starter
Member
Joined: 8 years ago

In the TED talk, Why children of immigrants experience guilt and strategies to cope by Sahaj Kaur Kohli, Sahaj talks about how immigrants can feel guilty about their past experiences and also that they don’t deserve what they have.  

In the novel, “Exit West” by Mohsin Hamid is about two main characters who are lovers and they  experience the hardships of living in a war zone city. And eventually they find magical doors that help transport them to different parts of the world. The main characters Saeed and Nadia deal with guilt with the fact that they are more fortunate than others because they have survived the warzone and are still together and the fact that they left people they cared about behind. 

“. . . but that is the way of things, for when we migrate, we murder from our lives those we leave behind.” (Hamid 98) This quote connects to Why children of immigrants experience guilt and strategies to cope because when you have sacrificed big parts of your life like family to be safe it will lead to a lot of guilt. “There’s also this sense of a thriver’s guilt or this guilt of growing, healing, accessing resources and opportunities that maybe our parents didn't have or our family and other parts of the world don't have access to.” (1:06 Kohli) 

Has anyone in your novel felt guilty with the fact that they have a better life than people that experienced the same things as them?

_____________________________________

For participants: 

-Never use a peer’s real name, only use their username

-Respond to the question based on your book, not your personal opinion

-If the question doesn’t directly apply to something that appears in your book, be clear about what you’re seeing instead

 

-Make sure to include a summary of your book so far

-Include a quote with the proper citation to give context to your answer

-Reply to one other participant in this group

-Acknowledge your lead’s reply to your response with a comment that clarifies information, offer a question to them about their book, or simply give a thumbs up

To exceed: Reply to three other people in this group, or two in this group and one in a group you weren’t assigned

8 Replies
Posts: 17
Protobeing
Joined: 1 year ago

In my book, The Only Road, by Alexandra Diaz, a 12 year old boy and his 15 year old girl cousin flee Guatemala to live with the boy's brother in Texas. The girl’s name is Angela, and the boy’s name is Jaime. Jaime’s cousin, Angela’s brother, Miguel, is killed after refusing to join a local corrupt gang, called the Alphas. The Alphas then give Angela a letter saying her and Jaime have to join them in return for Miguel refusing. Jaime and Angela’s family arrange for them to flee to America, by truck, bus, train, and bribery, to live with their brother in a land where they will have a life. They face lots of challenges along the way, meet lots of friends and enemies, and are currently hopping trains in Northern Mexico to try to reach the border. I think Jaime explicitly feels lots of guilt for what happened to his cousin, and for the sacrifices his family made to get him to a better place. Angela is implied to share this guilt, but she covers it up better than Jaime does. They both feel a great deal of guilt, but realize they are lucky and loved by their family and take full advantage of the situation. 

"Papa, Mama, Abuela, Miguel, Tios Daniel and Rosario, Rosita with her baby Quico. He missed them. Maybe he should have let The Alphas recruit him, just to see his family every day. --- Like Xavi, he could only hope that this whole journey would be worth it. He owed his family that much" (Diaz 181).

Reply
1 Reply
Joined: 1 year ago

Protobeing
Posts: 18

You referenced that Angela and Jamie feel guilt but Jamie shows it more. In my book it is sometimes said but it is usually implied in conversation and through things the main characters do. How exactly does Jamie show it more compared to Angela?

Reply
Posts: 7
Protobeing
Joined: 1 year ago

In my book The Lines We Cross by Randa Abdel-Fattah, there isn´t an example of guilt exactly, but there is an example of a character hearing another characters story and looking horrifed. Mina, a girl from Afgahnistan is explaining to Michael, who´s parents are part of an anti immigration organization her experinences in Afgahnistan. ¨As for my dad, well, he´s dead. Do you want all the gory details or are you so cold it wouldn´t even make a difference? Micheal stands there at me, a horrified look on his face.¨ (Abdel-Fattah 172) Micheal had never come close to anything that she had gone through, sure he might feel bad and say sorry, but there isn´t any guilt in him for living a better life. 

Reply
3 Replies
Joined: 1 year ago

Protobeing
Posts: 18

You say that the character Michael hasn't been through anything as close as Mina, what things specifically other than her dads death has she gone through? 

Reply
Joined: 1 year ago

Protobeing
Posts: 17

Are Michael's parents sort of antagonists in your book? If they are anti-immigration does that cause conflict between Michael and his parents?

Reply
Joined: 1 year ago

Protobeing
Posts: 7

Michael being his parents son, their beliefs are pushed on to him and he accepts those beliefs. There is no conflict between Michael and his parents.  

Reply
Posts: 14
Protobeing
Joined: 1 year ago

In my novel "The House on Mango Street" the character Ezperanza doesn't feel guilty for having a better life than some immigrants. Frankly, because she lives in a primarily white area in Chicago. 

Reply
1 Reply
Joined: 1 year ago

Protobeing
Posts: 18

What is it like for Ezperanza living in a primarily white area in Chicago? 

Reply
Share: