TheUtmostTrouble TheUtmostTrouble
Notifications
Clear all

2. Group H - p.lizotte25

8 Posts
6 Users
0 Likes
170 Views
Posts: 120
Admin
Topic starter
Member
Joined: 8 years ago

In the TED Talk “What Marrying an Immigrant Taught Me About Cultural Bias” Kyle Quinn talks about how his wife Isabella who was originally born from Brazil who he met on a year-long exchange program since he was learning Portuguese and how his wife gets treated by other people just because of her origin and how she had a “temporary” green card which meant she wasn’t an “American citizen”.  

 

In the TED Talk the author talks about how his wife Isabella was struggling with how society was treating her just because the worker at the BMV noticed Isabella had a green card which the worker had started to discriminate her a bit and then asked her husband where his green card was assuming that since she wasn’t a U.S citizen that her husband wouldn’t be either, a quote that supports my explanation on discrimination is this legal system does nothing to protect them from the hate, discrimination, or dehumanization they experience on a daily basis in the U.S”. (Quinn) 

 

In my novel “Girl In Translation” by Jean Kwok it is about an 11-year-old girl who moved from Hong-Kong to New York with her mom which was a big cultural change for them as they spoke a different language, did their own things differently than others etc. Kimberly and her mom, who is called Ma in this novel, were looking around for apartments but the only ones they could find were described as no heat, no furniture, and kind of in a sketchy area. 

 

Kimberly and her mom were faced with many different challenges just like Kyle’s wife isabella in the novel, kimberly was faced with struggles, discrimination, hate, and rude comments or looks. A quote that explains what i am saying is when Kimberly had met her cousin Nelson. “Nelson rolled his eyes “Welcome to America,""he leaned in to kiss my cheek and said softly, “you're a rake filled with dirt. A stupid country bumpkin.” (Kwok 10) 

 

The was that the ted talk and my novel connected was that both of these characters were faced with discrimination, struggling to “re-adapt” to their new environment,and they way U.S citizens treated them just because they were “different”. 

 

Are your characters struggling with being treated in their new environment? Do they recognize they are being treated differently from others? If so, how are they coping?

----

For participants: 

-Never use a peer’s real name, only use their username

-Respond to the question based on your book, not your personal opinion

-If the question doesn’t directly apply to something that appears in your book, be clear about what you’re seeing instead

 

-Make sure to include a summary of your book so far

-Include a quote with the proper citation to give context to your answer

-Reply to one other participant in this group

-Acknowledge your lead’s reply to your response with a comment that clarifies information, offer a question to them about their book, or simply give a thumbs up

To exceed: Reply to three other people in this group, or two in this group and one in a group you weren’t assigned

7 Replies
Posts: 7
Protobeing
Joined: 1 year ago

In my book Out of Nowhere written by Maria Padian, a high school soccer player named Tom Bouchard and his cousin gets caught vandalizing a mural of their rival school. Another big part of the story is all of the Somali kids coming to his school. he goes to school in Enniston which is just a made up name for Lewiston. He befriends Saeed, a Somali who is very good at soccer. Saeed teaches Tom about the culture of the area he's from and Tom tries his best to help Saeed learn about Enniston. Tom learns about all of the war and death where Saeed comes from and that Saeed has gone through a lot to get to Maine. Saeed mentions how many people he loved and his friends died in war. Saeed was moved to a camp by the UN, then he moved to Maine with his mother, sister and brother. This quote describes the connection with plizotte25 book. "Okay, my family live in Somalia, right? And in Somalia there is big, big wars and fighting. Like everyone is gets killed, and the peoples, they just ... run" (Padian). Barriers Saeed has to overcome language barriers and try to fit in with the culture. Saeed has seen people die and has been traumatized by that and has had many loved ones die. Saeed needs Tom's help when trying to communicate with people at school. With Toms help Saeed can become more fluent in English and make his time in Enniston way easier.

 
Reply
1 Reply
Joined: 1 year ago

Protobeing
Posts: 5

in my book Girl In Translation by Jean kwok. a girl named Kimberly originally from Hong Kong talks about how she moved all the way to New York when she was 11 years old. she moved with her mother who she calls Ma. Ma works in a factory so her and Kimberly can have a stable living in an apartment that isn't the best quality but it works. Kimberly struggles with "adapting" to her new environment within school, hanging out with other people in her community and being treated different because she is being classified as different. When she first got there I guess you could say that people were careful around Kimberly because she was new, but once she lived in New York for longer she started developing more friendships and she even had a relationship with a guy named Matt that she met in the factory. Kimberly and Matt became very good friends in a short about of time, once they got older they started dating but then Kimberly got a job offer in Austin, Texas and Matt decided not to leave with Kimberly, but decided to stay with his mom which led them to break up and he got with a girl named Brittany. The novel ends 12 years later after the break-up and Kimberly is now successful as she lives in a grand house with Ma and her and matt's kid and she is no longer working in that factory and she is now a Heart Surgeon. Even though Kimberly was being treated different because she wasn't from New York and people would make fun of her and bring her down with words but in this novel it also shows that no matter how much hate she received because shes "different" she can still become very successful and become the best version of herself and can surround yourself with good people around you. 

A quote that shows that after all these years of Kimberly being picked on she was now a successful surgeon. "Even after all those years, I am still filled with awe each time I hold the knife in my hand, my patients are often small, so small that some have breathed out common air for only a few days, and here they lie under the scalpel." (Kwok 278) 

Did your character ever overcome their past with hate, discrimination or anything in that nature? if not did your character change for the better and got over it?.

Reply
Posts: 6
Protobeing
Joined: 1 year ago

In my book Out of Nowhere written by Maria Padian is about a Somali immigrant that moved to Enniston (Lewiston) that plays soccer and has to deal with the struggles of being a immigrant from Somalia. He has to overcome language barriers and trying to fit in with the other students. A big part of this book is that Tom Bouchard (the main character) was caught vandalizing a public mural at the Maquoit High School and they got in a lot of trouble for that. And this also relates to plizotte's book because both characters are struggling with the way they are treated.

in my book the characters are struggling with the way they are being treated. "Can we not talk about Samira right now? Im sort of like the mayor. A little maxed out on Somalis." this is showing how they are struggling because people are making jokes that they do not realize is making as much of a impact on them than he knows. and they do recognize they are being treated differently and they cope with it in many ways but one of them is sticking up for themselves and making the other person know that it was not okay to make those kinds of jokes and that it hurts them.

Reply
1 Reply
Joined: 1 year ago

Protobeing
Posts: 17

In my book we are all that’s left written by Carrie Arcos, Zara has lost herself due to a bombing that happened to her, Nadja (Zara mother) and (Benny) her little brother. They all got hurt but not as much as her mother. She's in a coma at the hospital with a lot of injuries. They don't know what or when she will wake up. They are switching from P.O.V from Nadja and Zara and we get to learn more about what her mother was doing before she came to Visegrad. They show how she lived, what she did when the war was going on and what she did to survive and to get to where she was today before she lost all of her friends and family. I agree with your book because they are both new people in a class and they are both trying to fit in with students. "I sit it on the desk and try to hide in the back of the room, but it's impossible." (Arcos)

Reply
Posts: 16
Protobeing
Joined: 1 year ago

In the novel “My Father, the Panda Killer.” by (Jamie Jo Hoang) it splits the story between Jane and her father, Phuc. Jane lives with her little brother Paul, and her father Phuc who is an escaped immigrant. Jane is 17 and wants to go to college but is terrified to ask her father for permission to go. She is afraid of being beaten for wanting to leave and not work at the store like her father. She is also afraid of her brother hating her for leaving like their mother.    When Phuc was young he had to try to escape his hometown to get to America; but fails the first time and lands up getting an older man killed because of his  arrogance. The second time he succeeds and gets out of his home town.       Jane finally spills about being accepted to college at dinner when her fathers company was visiting.  The lady was questioning her if she would like to go to college or if she's undecided; when this happened she couldn't take the pressure and just yelled out that she'd been accepted. Her father to her surprise just said okay and nothing more.         The second time Phuc attempts to escape he is on another boat. And it makes it further than last time, being stopped a few times to be checked and paying off the people to continue the trip, then the ship broke down and they were stranded, being passed up multiple times by other boats. At last Phuc thinks of fishing, dives for the fish and when he comes back up the boat is gone and there is a shark playing with him. When he finds and swims back to the boat he keeps passing out and then there is a lot of commotion, when he gains consciousness he realizes everyones dead except 1 person. Later just one other gains consciousness and now it's Phuc and two others.  Phuc has but together it was pirates that killed, tortured, and robbed the people on the ship.      Jane went to Disneyland. When she gets back work is even more boring than it has been because there is no excitement except for her friend showing up and giving her coffee. The next day she was late picking up her brother and they had already called her father and she knew she was in for a world of hurt. When she was in the car she got hit multiple times and when she got home she got beat more with a stick till she physically couldn't move. Later her brother brought her soup and her stuffed panda her father won at a carnival game for her, creating the one good memory she has of him and one she cherishes most.  

 I don't really see Jane or phuc struggling with their surroundings or them recognizing they are being treated differently.  But after  Jane is done being beaten she lays down and her brother, Paul, brings her a bowl of soup and she explains that “This is the first time Paul made it for me. Usually, it's me trying to distract him from my bruises, winsing, or general bad mood. I forced myself to sit up and smile.” (Hoang 166) even though she knows her brother knows what happened she still tries to make it seem okay and that everythings alright.

Reply
Posts: 17
Protobeing
Joined: 1 year ago

In my book we are all that’s left written by Carrie Arcos, Zara has lost herself due to a bombing that happened to her, Nadja (Zara mother) and (Benny) her little brother. They all got hurt but not as much as her mother. She's in a coma at the hospital with a lot of injuries. They don't know what or when she will wake up. They are switching from P.O.V from Nadja and Zara and we get to learn more about what her mother was doing before she came to Visegrad. They show how she lived, what she did when the war was going on and what she did to survive and to get to where she was today before she lost all of her friends and family. 

While they have not come to America yet in the novel I have been wondering what they will do once they arrive. And what the challenges and what will be the struggles they deal with when going to America.

In my novel my character is struggling with being the new student in a photograph class. “Um, I don’t think I’m going to be able to keep taking this class.” (Arcos) she is struggling with being new, there was a bombing that happened to her and Zara feels like she is being looked at by everyone and they don't like her and they say things under her breath. They also give her dirty looks when she speaks or shows her pictures to the class. Zara copes with her pain in many different ways; Zara talks to her father about what they do and he makes her feel better about herself.

Reply
Posts: 5
Protobeing
Joined: 1 year ago

in my book Girl In Translation by Jean kwok. a girl named Kimberly originally from Hong Kong talks about how she moved all the way to New York when she was 11 years old. she moved with her mother who she calls Ma. Ma works in a factory so her and Kimberly can have a stable living in an apartment that isn't the best quality but it works. Kimberly struggles with "adapting" to her new environment within school, hanging out with other people in her community and being treated different because she is being classified as different. When she first got there I guess you could say that people were careful around Kimberly because she was new, but once she lived in New York for longer she started developing more friendships and she even had a relationship with a guy named Matt that she met in the factory when she was a little bit younger. 

In my novel Girl In Translation connects with zpelletier25 novel because both of our characters had grown up with struggled that they had to face because they both were new and had to deal with rude classmates, teachers that don't really help out if they don't understand what they need to do or what is being asked. 

Was there any other ways that your character had coped with the bullying?

Reply
Share: